Costco's sustainability record is dominated by three critical failures: Scope 3 emissions rising 9% since 2020 despite intensity claims; zero deforestation commitments across palm, beef, soy, and wood while driving boreal forest destruction via Kirkland tissue; and explicit rejection of SBTi validation. Shareholder activism, not board leadership, has forced minimal action.
Same formula for every company. No curve. No private weighting.
SINK = (0.3 × Base + 0.7 × Performance) × ScaleStrongest on Controversies & Red Flags and Carbon Footprint — Operations (6/10, 5/10). Weakest on Nature & Biodiversity Impact and Emissions Trajectory (2/10, 2/10).
12 sources used in this assessment. All publicly available. Each row shows which rubric questions it informed.
9 of 12 sources are third-party verified or public record.
If you believe a source has been misread or a newer version exists, submit a challenge.
Among the 43 major retail (non-fashion) brands we've scored, Costco Wholesale sits 42nd of 43.
Score history begins 4 April 2026.
As Costco Wholesale's score updates, the trajectory will appear here.
We're backfilling historical scores for FTSE 100 and S&P 100 companies over the coming weeks.
Every challenge is published. We'd rather be corrected than wrong — that's the whole point.
No challenges submitted yet. If you have evidence that contradicts this score, you can challenge any question above — cite a public source and we'll review it.
Costco Wholesale is the world's largest membership-based retailer, operating 890+ warehouses globally. Founded in 1983 and headquartered in Issaquah, Washington, it generated $275 billion in FY2025 revenue and employs 316,000 people. The company operates a bulk-sales model and is a major vendor of fresh meat, seafood, and packaged goods.
Larger US retailer; similarly high Scope 3 emissions but ahead on renewable energy and SBTi validation.
View breakdown →US discount retailer peer; also faces deforestation and supply chain transparency criticism.
View breakdown →Major meat supplier to Costco; shares severe scope 3 emissions and deforestation risk in beef and poultry.
View breakdown →Comparable scale and Scope 3 dominance; further ahead on SBTi targets and forest commitments but still contested.
View breakdown →Email alerts when a rubric question is verified, a challenge is resolved, or the overall score changes.
One email, every Sunday. Score changes, new research, the stories behind the numbers. Free.
No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.
Readers and institutions support our work. Companies can pay to submit evidence we couldn't find. Neither type of payment changes a score.